What is an -symmetric oracle problem?
Define invariant unitary or measurement oracles and compare query costs under explicit access conventions.
Discuss this questionDefine a black-box unitary commuting with collective , or a quantum instrument whose branch Kraus operators lie in that commutant. Specify access to inverses or controlled queries when meaningful, ancillas, and the classical comparison model. Find a natural promise task with different classical, quantum, or witness-assisted query costs.
A quantum instrument does not literally commute with a unitary in the operator sense. Mere covariance of a channel is also weaker than requiring invariant Kraus operators and need not imply the same sector conservation.
Why this is interesting
Query complexity depends on the permitted coherent access and on what information each oracle response reveals.
Explicit variants
Superpolynomial query separation
Construct an explicitly defined invariant oracle family and a promise problem solvable with STP-oracle queries but requiring superpolynomial or exponential classical queries. State how the classical oracle interface exposes the same input instance. Charge for oracle preparation, controlled access, inverses, and reference-frame resources whenever they are required.
Symmetric versions of known separations
Formulate -symmetric analogues of Simon, forrelation, hidden-subgroup, or welded-tree problems. Preserve an explicit comparison of input size, promise, and classical/quantum access, and identify which operation supplies the separation in the invariant model.
Speedups lost under a symmetry restriction
For a specified oracle separation, impose an symmetry restriction on both preparation and access. Determine whether the separation survives with comparable query cost. If it fails, identify the unavailable operation and ask whether a different invariant task or primitive restores an advantage.
Equivariant channels and invariant instruments
Compare a covariant channel satisfying with the stricter oracle whose individual Kraus operators are invariant on a fixed register. For each model, define coherent, inverse, controlled, and classical access where those notions exist. Determine which sector or multiplicity information each query can change or reveal.
A place to start
Start with two invariant oracles distinguished by their action on a small multiplicity space and derive the optimal one-query discrimination probability.
Related work
These works provide context and established results. They need not be the origin of this exact formulation.
Discuss this question
Reading is public. Posting requires a GitHub account. You can also write to Kunal.